RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   Brushless (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Toro 1/8 Combo (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=28583)

berserk80 11.15.2010 07:16 AM

Toro 1/8 Combo
 
Hello
Funny Chinese people got to MMM
Toro parse here http://forum.rcdesign.ru/f71/thread210667.html

suicideneil 11.15.2010 09:29 AM

Hmm, the power & brainboard layout is rather similar isnt it, not cool really. I saw that Hobbywing have new sensored 1/10 & 1/8 escs the other day; everybody is ripping off castle these days, hard to do much about patent infringements with companies in china... :no:

bigbadtaz 11.15.2010 12:25 PM

castle don't build stuff here they get it from china and articles i have had read these companies that are coming out now have been OEM for a lot of companies . so don't think they are ripping off castle now if they were made in the USA then another company did the same thing you my have a point. and if castle had a case don't you think they would be shut down or sued.

mistercrash 11.15.2010 01:10 PM

From what I know, and I don't know much, Castle imports small electronic components and parts from overseas so they can assemble their systems in the USA in their USA based factory. Systems that have been engineered from the ground up by Castle Creations USA. If an overseas company, or any other company copies Castle Creations products then I would say yes, they are ripping off Castle.

JThiessen 11.15.2010 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigbadtaz (Post 387631)
castle don't build stuff here they get it from china and articles i have had read these companies that are coming out now have been OEM for a lot of companies . so don't think they are ripping off castle now if they were made in the USA then another company did the same thing you my have a point. and if castle had a case don't you think they would be shut down or sued.

Completely untrue. When a company "hires" another company (outsoursce) to fabricate parts for its products, those products are protected by international copyright law, and both companies sign numerous agreements saying such. Same goes for theories and ideas that companies identify as their "intellectual property".

Kcaz25 11.15.2010 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigbadtaz (Post 387631)
castle don't build stuff here they get it from china and articles i have had read these companies that are coming out now have been OEM for a lot of companies . so don't think they are ripping off castle now if they were made in the USA then another company did the same thing you my have a point. and if castle had a case don't you think they would be shut down or sued.

Wrong!

reno911 11.15.2010 02:03 PM

I have never been to that side of the world but from those I know who have and what I hear of these things. We only see a small small percentage of the chaoticness that is China/Japan/Korea/Taiwan/etc copies of everything. If something is made, from what I understand, there is at least two to three companies that make the exact same thing. If they all originate from the same source or not is still a mystery. Must be nice though in Japan you can buy an iPhone, an uPhone, and an ePhone.

I have to EZrun esc's I have taken them apart, they may be similar to the MMM but they are on a lower standard. I imagine this copy is of the same standards.

BrianG 11.15.2010 02:08 PM

I have personally been to the actual Castle facility in Olathe Kansas and can attest they DO design and build their circuits on site. But I am sure they get their components wherever they can get them, just like everyone else. They have their component picker/placers (whatever their technical name is), and soldering systems in their KS site.

Most if not all of their motors are built overseas, but they are built in Castle-run factories over there and the design is Castle's (with Neu license).

BigBagTaz, please refrain from posting information that is untrue, and really downright slanderous.

BrianG 11.15.2010 02:10 PM

I just looked at that Toro page and noticed that their rotors are not wrapped at all. I wonder how well they'll hold up spinning at 40,000rpm+?

That system does look a LOT like the MMM system through, particularly the brain board. And the program card looks suspiciously familiar as well.

Motors seem to be 9 slot stator and 6 slot rotor. kinda odd...

suicideneil 11.15.2010 03:19 PM

Yeah, lack of wrapping on the rotor is rather iffy, especially with those 6 big magnets just stuck to the core like that- if it was done well, it might be a beasty motor, but I think it'll end up grenading like that kid's did back along who had another cheap MMM motor clone.

And yeah, Castle have posted indepth photo tours of their manufacturing facility on rc-monster; chips are sourced overseas ( same with 99% of every other electrical appliance ) but are assembled in the USA by American Engineers ( it does actually state this on Castle's website too ). I do dislike listening to ill-informed people spouting off.... :no:

snellemin 11.15.2010 04:26 PM

Brain board looks mighty similar to the old Castle brain board. Looking closely I can see that a few items have been moved around for it not to be considered a total clone. But why worry really? Castle new brain boards are smaller.

old boards comparison
http://i189.photobucket.com/albums/z...%20esc/023.jpg

http://forum.rcdesign.ru/attachment....7&d=1289747862




Newer board

http://i189.photobucket.com/albums/z...c/DSCF0238.jpg

What's_nitro? 11.15.2010 05:17 PM

Translated page, FYI...

http://translate.google.com/translat...7.html&act=url

brian015 11.15.2010 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by What's_nitro? (Post 387667)

good read...my favorites:

Good people have brought another set of "our brothers".

Sasha, what is the fear of a motor?

:wink:

What's_nitro? 11.15.2010 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brian015 (Post 387673)
good read...my favorites:

Good people have brought another set of "our brothers".

Sasha, what is the fear of a motor?

:wink:

Don't forget the chamomile and jellyfish......... :lol:

simplechamp 11.15.2010 07:22 PM

To me it looks like they are trying to make it look similar to the Tekin RX8 with the red heatsink and solder posts.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:42 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.